Why Being Nice This Holiday Season is Ruining Your Joy

5 Ways You're Hurting Your Holidays

The holiday season is supposed to be a time of joy, relaxation, and togetherness. However, for many, it becomes a time of stress, exhaustion, and disappointment. If you've ever found yourself feeling more frazzled than festive, you're not alone. One of the key reasons people struggle during the holidays is that they are trying too hard to be "nice" – often at the expense of their own well-being. But why does this happen, and how can you break free from the cycle of holiday burnout?

Let's take a gander at why people feel compelled to go above and beyond during the holidays, how this drive for niceness may actually be ruining your holiday experience, and, most importantly, how you can reclaim some holiday happiness. If you've found yourself overwhelmed by the expectations that come with this time of year, this post is for you.

The Illusion of "Being Nice" During the Holidays

One of the most common holiday traps people fall into is the belief that being excessively nice is the key to having a successful holiday season. There's a lot of pressure to be cheerful, generous, and accommodating, but often, this need to be nice creates more stress than happiness.

When we think of the holidays, we often envision a perfect scene of joyful family gatherings, generous gift exchanges, and everyone coming together with warmth and good cheer. The expectation is that we should give our best selves to others, offering kindness, hospitality, and love. This drive to please everyone, however, can lead to emotional burnout and disappointment, especially when reality doesn’t live up to the ideal.

The Pressure to Be "Perfectly Nice" at the Expense of Self-Care

At its core, the holiday season often becomes a performance. People feel like they need to live up to a picture-perfect version of themselves: the ideal hostess, the perfect gift-giver, the ever-optimistic friend or family member. Social media exacerbates this pressure, with images of perfectly decorated homes, beautifully wrapped presents, and smiling families who seem to have it all together. But the truth is, the drive to be nice can quickly become overwhelming.

Many people mistakenly believe that their problem is a lack of time, money, or resources. The reality, however, is often deeper than that. The true issue lies in the expectation that you must constantly please others, even when it means sacrificing your own happiness. Trying to meet everyone else’s needs without prioritizing your own can lead to frustration, burnout, and resentment.

Why Being "Too Nice" is Actually Hurting Your Holidays

While being nice in moderation is undoubtedly a good thing, when we overextend ourselves to the point of exhaustion, the very thing that’s meant to bring joy turns into a source of stress. Here are some reasons why trying to be "too nice" can actually sabotage your holiday season:

1. Burnout and Exhaustion

Spending days or even weeks preparing for holiday events, buying presents, cooking large meals, and attending numerous social gatherings can leave you physically and mentally drained. The constant need to be pleasant and accommodating – especially when you’re already worn out – leads to burnout. Instead of feeling rejuvenated and joyful during the holidays, you might feel like you need a vacation from the holiday itself.

Solution: Recognize that it’s okay to say “no.” You don’t have to attend every holiday event or accept every invitation. Prioritize your mental and physical health by setting boundaries and allowing time for rest. It’s essential to understand that self-care isn’t selfish; it’s necessary.

2. Unrealistic Expectations

A big part of the pressure to be nice stems from the unrealistic expectations we set for ourselves during the holiday season. We want to give the perfect gift, make the perfect meal, and host the perfect gathering. This perfectionism can lead to constant worry and stress.

Solution: Let go of the need for perfection. Holidays don’t need to be flawless in order to be meaningful. Instead of focusing on creating a flawless holiday experience, focus on creating a real holiday experience that’s about spending time with people you love and creating memories that matter. Imperfection is often where the best moments happen.

3. Financial Strain

The drive to give thoughtful gifts or host extravagant meals can quickly lead to financial strain. In trying to please others, many people end up overspending on gifts, decorations, and party supplies. This can create a lot of financial stress, which only adds to the overall pressure of the season.

Solution: You don't have to explain yourself to anyone and you don't have to give gifts because you did the year before. Change your thinking about holiday giving. The best gift isn’t always the most expensive or elaborate one. Instead of focusing on material things, consider giving the gift of time or experience – whether it’s a homemade meal, a heartfelt letter, or a shared adventure.

4. Neglecting Your Own Needs

In the hustle and bustle of pleasing others and being too nice, it’s easy to forget about your own needs and desires. You might find yourself stretched thin, attending every gathering and making sure everyone else is comfortable, while neglecting your own well-being. This means you're sacrificing time, sleep, energy to other people, when your body is asking for a break.

Solution: Make a commitment to prioritize your own needs, too. This could mean scheduling some alone time, asking for help when needed, or simply giving yourself permission to take a break. You don’t need to be everything to everyone. Take the time to rest, recharge, and reflect so you can enjoy the season for yourself, too.

The Real Problem: Fear of Disappointment

Many people mistakenly think their problem is simply that they aren’t doing enough during the holidays. However, the deeper issue is often the fear of disappointing others or falling short of expectations. The drive to be nice, generous, and accommodating stems from a fear of rejection or letting others down.

This fear leads to overcompensating by overextending yourself, over-spending, and over-scheduling. But no matter how much you do, you’ll never be able to please everyone, and this constant effort to meet external expectations will only lead to feelings of failure, frustration, and dissatisfaction.

Solution: Shift your mindset from trying to meet everyone else’s expectations to focusing on your own joy. Allow yourself to enjoy the holidays on your terms, without the pressure of pleasing others. Recognize that your worth is not determined by how much you give or how perfect your holiday season is.

How to Reclaim Your Holiday Joy

If you find yourself stuck in the cycle of trying to be too nice, it’s time to take a step back and reassess what the holidays mean to you. Here are some ways to reclaim the joy and magic of the season, without losing yourself in the process:

1. Set Realistic Boundaries

One of the most powerful tools you have during the holidays is the ability to set boundaries. You don’t have to do it all, and you certainly don’t have to say "yes" to everything. It’s okay to say "no" to events or activities that don’t align with your values or that will leave you feeling drained. Saying "no" is not about being rude; it’s about honoring your own needs.

2. Prioritize What Truly Matters

Instead of trying to do everything, focus on what matters most. Spend time with loved ones who uplift and energize you, not those who drain your energy. Focus on the relationships that bring joy, rather than trying to please everyone. This will help you create deeper, more meaningful memories.

3. Let Go of Perfectionism

The idea of a "perfect holiday" is often unrealistic and sets us up for disappointment. It’s important to embrace imperfection and remember that the best moments are often the unscripted ones. Instead of worrying about the details, focus on the experiences and the people you’re sharing them with.

4. Practice Gratitude

One of the best ways to shift your focus from the pressures of the season to the joy of the season is to practice gratitude. Take time each day to reflect on what you’re grateful for. This can help you appreciate the little things and create a sense of peace amidst the chaos.

5. Give Yourself Permission to Rest

Finally, allow yourself to rest. The holidays are meant to be a time of rejuvenation, not exhaustion. Whether it’s taking a nap, enjoying a cozy evening in, or spending time alone, make sure to carve out time for yourself. Rest is essential for maintaining your mental and emotional well-being, and it will allow you to enjoy the season more fully.

Embrace the Holiday Season Without Losing Yourself

The holidays are a time to celebrate, reflect, and connect with others, but trying to be excessively nice can undermine your ability to truly enjoy the season. If you’re feeling overwhelmed by the pressure to please others, it’s time to reassess your approach. Instead of focusing on being the "perfect" holiday host or gift-giver, prioritize your own well-being and embrace imperfection. Set boundaries, practice gratitude, and give yourself the gift of rest. In doing so, you’ll not only make your holiday season more enjoyable but also create space for deeper, more meaningful connections with those who truly matter.

The key to a joyful holiday season isn’t in doing more for others but in doing what feels right for you. So, this year, let go of the pressure to be everything to everyone, and allow yourself to simply be.

About the author: Jessica Miller is a licensed therapist in the state of California. Her background is in domestic violence, self-esteem, anxiety, trauma, and somatic experiencing. She believes that life is messy and sometimes we need someone to understand that we don't know wtf we're doing.

Schedule a consult today!